LeRoy: Evaluating the NHL Trade Deadline

The NHL trade deadline has come and gone. The most eventful exchange of the day happened right around 3:00, and the news did not break until around 3:30 as the Sabres and Canucks brought a blockbuster deal to an extremely quiet day. All in all, there were 16 trades. Here is an evaluation of each team’s day:

Anaheim Ducks
In: Mark Fraser (TOR) & Sebastian Erixon (VAN).
Out: Dale Mitchell (TOR) & Andrew Gordon (VAN).
Overall Grade: C
A simple set of minor league deals, the Ducks did not need to make any major changes, as they are the hottest team in the NHL since January 1. At that time, they were 20 points out of a playoff spot.
Expect this team to make the playoffs.

Boston Bruins
In: Brian Rolston (NYI), Mike Mottau (NYI), & Greg Zanon (MIN).
Out: Yannick Riendeau (NYI), Marc Cantin (NYI), & Steve Kampler (MIN).
Overall Grade: B-
The Bruins added depth in order to try and repeat as Stanley Cup champions. Greg Zanon and Mike Mottau are underrated veterans and will do well in Boston. Brian Rolston is back for another stint in Bean Town, coming in with a steep salary after clearing waivers. I do not think that he will be the Rolston of the past, but a homecoming could be what he needs to revitalize his career. If not, this will be viewed as a bad move.

Buffalo Sabres
In: Cody Hodgson (VAN), Alexander Sulzer (VAN), & 2012 1st Round Draft Pick (NSH).
Out: Paul Gaustad (NSH), Zack Kassian (VAN), Marc-Andre Gragnani (VAN), & 2013 4th Round Draft Pick (NSH).
Overall Grade: A
The Sabres pulled off the surprise move of the day, acquiring Calder Trophy candidate Cody Hodgson and sending super prospect Zack Kassian to Vancouver. Kassian appealed to fans at first, but after 27 games in the big leagues, it became evident that he wasn’t what the Sabres brass was looking for. This is an absolute steal for Buffalo. Last year, most people would have told Darcy Regier that he is crazy for trading Gragnani (Gragnani tied a Sabres playoff rookie record for points in a playoff series). Gragnani’s game has significantly fallen off this year and he has had a tough time cracking a lineup that conists of Tyler Myers, Robyn Regehr, Christian Ehrhoff, and Jordan Leopold, not to mention defenseman of the future Brayden McNabb. In a more predictable move, the Sabres sent fan favorite Paul Gaustad to the Western Conference. What is surprising is the fact that Buffalo received a 1st round pick. Regier made the Sabres better not just for the future, but for the present.

Chicago Blackhawks
In: Johnny Oduya (WPG) & 2012 5th Round Draft Pick.
Out: 2013 2nd Round Draft Pick (WPG), 2013 3rd Round Draft Pick (WPG), & John Scott (NYR).
Overall Grade: B-
This move isn’t as good as people might think. Jeremy Roenick would agree with me. The Blackhawks overpaid for Oduya, but that’s what happens when a team is trying to win the Cup. He is a good depth player and will likely fit in well with Steve Montador.

Colorado Avalanche
In: Jamie McGinn (SJ), Michael Sgarbossa (SJ), & Mike Connolly (SJ).
Out: Daniel Winnik (SJ), T.J. Galiardi (SJ), & 2013 7th Round Draft Pick.
Overall Grade: B
Colorado is essentially rebuilding again with these moves. They gave up some very good players but received some good prospects in return. Only time will tell if this move will pay off for a young Avalanche team.

Columbus Blue Jackets
In: 2012 4th Round Draft Pick (VAN)
Out: Samuel Pahlsson (VAN)
Overall Grade: B
The Blue Jackets receive a “B” because they waited to move Rick Nash until summer. Moving Carter was necessary and unfortunately didn’t pan out for the Blue Jackets. By waiting until summer, Scott Howson is going to have a plethora of offers (and much better ones). This will also enable more teams to get in on the bidding, even though Nash has a limited no trade clause. Moving Pahlsson was a good move, though given the market, Columbus may have been able to squeeze out more.

Detroit Red Wings
In: 2012 7th Round Draft Pick (Conditional) (TB).
Out: Mike Commodore (TB).
Overall Grade: B-
The Wings were able to shed some unnecessary salary by sending Commodore to Tampa Bay. Kyle Quincey provided a better option, so dumping Commodore was ideal. A 7th round pick in any organization might be frowned upon, but Detroit has the best scouting in the league’s history and will make that pick essentially worth a 4th.

Edmonton Oilers
In: Nick Schultz (MIN).
Out: Tom Gilbert (MIN).
Overall Grade: A-
The Oilers are going to be a formidable foe in the next few years, with numerous high draft picks such as Taylor Hall and Ryan Nugent-Hopkins already making a big difference, among others. Tom Gilbert is a solid player, but Nick Schultz is primed to take the reigns of this defense core and will thrive in Edmonton. He is a model of consistency (he is the Wild’s all time leader in games played) and will likely rack up more points with such a skilled set of forwards to work with in an offensive environment. Once the Oilers have a goaltender, they will be a playoff team for years to come.

Minnesota Wild
In: Tom Gilbert (EDM) & Steve Kampfer (BOS).
Out: Nick Schultz (EDM) & Greg Zanon (BOS).
Overall Grade: C
The Wild shook up their defense by trading Zanon and staple Nick Schultz. Unfortunately, the Wild appear to be in a shape similar to that of Colorado’s situation; rebuilding in a time in which the team should be trending upwards.

Montreal Canadiens
In: 2013 2nd Round Draft Pick (NSH) & 2013 5th Round Draft Pick (Conditional) (NSH).
Out: Andrei Kostitsyn (NSH).
Overall Grade: B
The Canadiens sent Kostitsyn to Nashville to be reunited with brither Sergei. The rebuilding team acquired 2 picks, making the deal worthwhile. This is a good move and has been a good week for the franchise that will benefit them in the long run.

Nashville Predators
In: Paul Gaustad (BUF), Andrei Kostitsyn (MTL), 2013 4th Round Draft Pick (BUF).
Out: 2012 1st Round Draft Pick, 2013 2nd Round Draft Pick (MTL), & 2013 5th Round Draft Pick (Conditional) (MTL).
Overall Grade: A-
The Predators are touted as the winners on deadline day, having solidified their depth and added scoring in order to go deep into the playoffs. This is by far the boldest we have ever seen the Preds at the deadline. They also added Hal Gill last week. Despite overpaying for Gaustad, they have a center that adds size, toughness, PK ability, and faceoff wins. Gaustad will be a good player for the team should they be able to get past the first few rounds. Kostitsyn is a good addition, as he will be reunited with his brother, automatically providing chemistry.

New York Islanders
In: Yannick Riendeau (BOS) & Marc Cantin (BOS).
Out: Brian Rolston (BOS) & Mike Mottau (BOS).
Overall Grade: B
The Islanders made a good move for the future that also makes them better today, believe it or not. They were able to dump Brian Rolston’s salary after nobody claimed him on waivers. Adding two younger players from the Bruins system is a plus. All in all, a good move for the organization.

New York Rangers
In: John Scott (CHI).
Out: 2012 5th Round Draft Pick (CHI)
Overall Grade: B-
The Rangers failed to make a significant move that would bolster their Eastern Conference lead. They are the favorites in the East to win it all and frankly, they probably did not need to make a deal (though they lack scoring). Dropping out of the Rick Nash trade last second is a sign of growth for the organization, as they were not willing to give up more than what was necessary to acquire him. I would bet on the Rangers to go and get Nash come this offseason, especially if New York wins the Stanley Cup this spring.

Ottawa Senators
In: Matt Gilroy (TB).
Out: Brian Lee (OTT).
Overall Grade: C
Nothing special here, but Gilroy adds depth to the defense in Ottawa. He will be a good 3rd or 4th defenseman for the Sens going into the playoffs.

San Jose Sharks
In: Daniel Winnik (COL), T.J, Galiardi (COL), & 2013 7th Round Draft Pick (COL).
Out: Jamie McGinn (COL), Michael Sgarbossa (COL), & Mike Connolly (COL).
Overall Grade: B
The Sharks did a good job adding balance to their attack for the playoffs. Galiardi could excel with the amount of skill that San Jose has and could be one of the better additions in today’s activities. Keep an eye on him as the season goes on.

Tampa Bay Lightning
In: Mike Commodore (DET), Keith Aulie (TOR), & Brian Lee (OTT).
Out: 2013 7th Round Draft Pick (Conditional) (DET), Carter Ashton (TOR), & Matt Gilroy (OTT).
Overall Grade: B-
Steve Yzerman has been very active in reshaping the Lightning. He has done so without jeopardizing a possible run for 8th place in the East. The centerpieces of the team have remained, while shuffling smaller pieces around. Commodore is a solid veteran that has won before, and Aulie and Lee are good young players that could play a role in Tampa’s future.

Toronto Maple Leafs
In: Carter Ashton (TB) & Dave Mitchell (ANA).
Out: Keith Aulie (TB) & Mark Fraser (ANA).
Overall Grade: C-
The Leafs were the biggest disappointment for all the yapping that GM Brian Burke did in the days prior to deadline day. The steeply declining Leafs are not just losing badly, they did not improve their playoff chances at all today, despite landing a good prospect in Ashton.

Vancouver Canucks
In: Zack Kassian (BUF), Marc-Andre Gragnani (BUF), Andrew Gordon (ANA), & Samuel Pahlsson (CBJ).
Out: Cody Hodgson (BUF), Alexander Sulzer (BUF), Sebastian Erixon (ANA), & 2012 4th Round Draft Pick (CBJ).
Overall Grade: B
The Canucks are taking an enormous gamble by moving Calder candidate Hodgson to Buffalo. They are however adding a highly touted prospect in Kassian, though he has not lived up to expectations. Gragnani has potential and was acquired at a cheap price. Pahlsson is a good third line center with a Stanley Cup ring and will be a good depth guy for the team.